Five College Football Underdog Coaches

We’re right in the middle of the college football season. It’s crazy how fast the season flies by after we look forward to it through the whole summer. 

Let’s take a look at five active coaches who have been great in the underdog role (Against the Spread). Some coaches are just great at getting their team to be ready to go when they are being counted out by many. These ATS records go back to 2005. 

Brian Kelly (40-22-2 ATS) LSU isn’t going to be an underdog very often, but the Tigers are going to be a dog in Tuscaloosa against Alabama on November 4. LSU pulled off the upset at home last year. Can they do it two years in a row? Kelly has been a good ATS moneymaker in general, but he has been excellent in this role. 

Matt Rhule (35-18 ATS) Rhule did some great work at Baylor. He struggled in the NFL, but I’m convinced Rhule is still a good college football head coach. Nebraska picked up a nice win at Illinois recently, and the Cornhuskers are starting to play a little better in the trenches. It won’t be a quick fix here, but this Nebraska team is definitely in a better spot than they were with Scott Frost as their leader. The Nebraska last three games will be interesting: home vs. Maryland, at Wisconsin, and at Iowa. 

Chris Creighton (45-28-1 ATS) Creighton is an excellent coach who gets the most out of his talent on an annual basis. Eastern Michigan is well known for playing in close games consistently. Creighton’s teams are 27-12 ATS as an underdog on the road. The Eagles will be a road underdog several more times this season. 

Craig Bohl (42-28 ATS) Here’s another guy who absolutely gets the most out of his team. Craig Bohl’s Wyoming teams make the most of their home field advantage at elevation in Laramie. They are strong in the trenches, and they play some good defense. Wyoming won’t wow you, but they are always a tough team to play. Texas struggled for three quarters against this group. Wyoming pulled off the upsets over Fresno State and Texas Tech at home as well. 

Billy Napier (19-8 ATS) Florida fans aren’t terribly high on Billy Napier right now, but I think they need to give him some time. Napier has been doing better with recruiting, and he has proven he can get kids up to play in these tough spots. An average or worse coach isn’t able to do this. The Gators play a really tough schedule, and they are going to be underdogs several more times. Don’t be surprised if they pull off a big upset sometime between now and the end of the season.